Happier and More Economical Holidays are Possible!

by Aysha Griffin

For three weeks each year, from mid-December until the end of the first week in January, my childhood home smelled of fragrant pine, special foods and anticipation of gifts and family fun. I thought Christmas, with its lights, carols and window-shopping on Fifth Avenue, was a national holiday, without any religious connotation. Although marketing was in its infancy and we were still called “citizens,” and not “consumers,” wanting new and better stuff seems part of human nature. But this was the days before ubiquitous credit cards, so we bought what we actually had the money to buy.

As an urban/suburban family, we enjoyed the “adventure” of buying a tree for the living room which we – mom, dad and three daughters – decorated from the large cardboard box marked “Xmas” that lived most of the year in the attic. On Xmas morning, we were giddy with the many wrapped packages Santa had left with our names on them, although we knew Santa was really Dad.

But before we could begin opening our presents, we had to set the dining room table with the Christmas China, make breakfast while Perry Como crooned on the phonograph, and enjoy our waffles and juice. Finally, when we were all done eating, the table cleared and dishes washed, we gathered in the living room as each one, round robin, was given a gift, knowing the best would be last.

We took our time, each present appreciated, talked about, assembled if necessary, tried out or tried on. It took most of the day, punctuated by “Happy Holidays!” phone calls from relatives and friends, snacks like candied nuts and sugar cookies, dancing and singing along to records, laughter and hugs. It was the only annual tradition we had, and it was – especially in retrospect – wonderful.

As time and life events drove us apart, I lost that celebratory time of year. But I got it back in the middle of my life, thanks to a mother-in-law who also loved the year-end holidays and celebrated them similarly to my then-long-deceased parents. It was during this time that I experienced…

The worst Christmas ever.

The luxury condo overlooking the ski slopes in Aspen should have made the holiday idyllic, but for the family dynamics of distant relations who had invited us — a couple and their two teenagers. We arrived Christmas eve and were awakened early Christmas morning to be ushered into the living room to open presents, before even having coffee!

We took seats while the father distributed all the wrapped gifts at once and then sat down. Each had at their feet a mountain of colorful boxes and gift bags, while we had a few gifts we’d made or bought for each other. “One, two, three, go!” said the father, and we watched in amazement as they began ripping apart the wrapping, tossing it aside, giving the item a cursory look, and on to the next. It was like a massacre.

“This isn’t the color I wanted,” whined the girl. “I was really hoping for the next model,” sulked the boy. “Don’t worry,” said the mom, “We can exchange everything.” Even she told her husband she’d hoped the diamond earrings he’d bought her were larger. “You can exchange them,” he said.  And with that, the gifts were carried in armfuls to their respective rooms and Christmas was over. No show-and-tell, no expressions of gratitude or kisses, no Perry Como, or even Kenny G.  We left after lunch.

Now, for…

The best Christmas ever.

I was 30 and my then-new partner and I were struggling to make ends meet. We lived in a studio apartment in the foothills west of Denver, on a property owned by a brilliant eccentric named Darwin. There were other rental units and all of us, having become friends, decided to celebrate “a modest Christmas.”

Darwin laid down the rules: no retail shopping, only things you already own or can buy for under $5, no wrapping paper except “the funny pages” from the newspaper. Twenty or more friends and family gathered late Christmas morning in Darwin’s living room, a fire blazing in the fireplace. We brought homemade food to share – cinnamon rolls, pumpkin bread, quiche – and with paper plates and cups of hot coffee, tea or cider in hand, we sat down to exchange gifts one at a time. We exclaimed, commented, joked. There was no hurry. We had all day to simply enjoy each other’s company.

I received a package of #2 pencils, a smooth rock painted with the word “Love,” a roll of toilet paper in which words of wisdom had been inserted on slips of stiff paper so they fell out as you unrolled it in use. Fun, original gifts I recall even decades later. We gave each other what we already had and wanted to share: books, compilations of music, clothing, jewelry, household items, and homemade Kahlua. Those who played an instrument played, while we danced and sang and ate and laughed all day, and well into the night. 

Of course, a great holiday celebration is not about the money, but about the spirit of appreciation and sense of connection. It can be wonderful to delight a loved one with a special costly gift they want, if you can afford it. But, in fact, most people spend more during the holidays than they can afford. They spend on obligatory gifts and travel, and that doesn’t include the emotional toll in seasonal stress, which is well documented.

For example, according to NerdWallet’s 2018 Holiday Travel Report, nearly half (49%) of Americans plan on spending money this holiday season on flights and/or hotels, The holiday travelers planning to use a credit card will charge $1,456 on average for travel related expenses — a combined $135.8 billion. Although, on average, card-using travelers paid off 2017 holiday travel credit card debt in 2.2 months, 5% say they’re still paying for it. If 2018 holiday travelers pay off their expenses in 2.2 months, they’ll rack up a collective $2.8 billion in interest.

$2.8 BILLION IN INTEREST! And that’s just on travel! So, as both a traveler and an advocate of “creative gift giving,” I’d like to share…

A few money and stress-saving tips:

Flights: While a Google blog recommends August or September buys for year-end holidays, if you haven’t yet bought tickets your best bet for cheaper flights is flexibility. Try searching a few days before and after your desired dates, and other airports if they are within driving distance. You can also set up email alerts so you’ll know when prices fluctuate. If you find a great deal through a consolidator (Expedia, Travelocity, etc.), go directly to the airline’s website and buy there. If you have problems later, you can deal with the carrier and not a third party.

Bringing/sending gifts: NerdWallet’s survey also found a third of Americans will use a checked bag to get gifts to their final destination if they fly for the holidays. Checked bags cost $25 on average, and up to $50 with some airlines. If you’re adding a second checked bag it may double the cost. Consider buying online and sending the gift directly to your destination. Free shipping and gift wrapping are often available. Or consider mailing packages in advance.

Gifts: Are “retail store-bought” gifts obligatory? I know that in some families and circles they are. But many people would be relieved if you called off the whole notion, or set some limits. Might you share something from your heart, perhaps a recycled or vintage item, or an experience? How about a gift certificate for a spa, tickets to a live show, or (my favorite!) your own “gift certificate” that entitles the bearer to something they would value?

My personal well-received gift certificates have included free hours of my professional services. Friends don’t like to ask if I can write or edit something for them, review their business plan, coach them on a challenge, or organize their wardrobe. If you know that someone would appreciate your expertise, or simply your time and attention, give him/her the gift of freely claiming it by redeeming the certificate. 

Most people I know do not really need anything, so I try to think of what would delight them, and that means personalized.

Some of my favorite gift ideas:

– An art card with a sincere handwritten note of appreciation. (When’s the last time you received one of those?)
– A basket full of all sorts of goodies you choose (e.g., fruits, dried fruits, crackers, jams, teas and coffees, honey, a new tea towel, candles, incense, a bottle of wine). And after the gift is consumed, the basket will remind them of your thoughtfulness.
– Anything handmade or personally created, by you or someone with whom you shared a connection. Even simple gifts with a story – like the artisan you met at the fair or in your travels and loved her work – makes the gift more meaningful.
– A gift card to Kiva.org. For as little as $25 each, you can give – especially to young people who spend a lot of time online – the opportunity to make a real difference in the life of someone, somewhere in the world. They must go to Kiva.org and choose a business to help support. At the end of the loan period (12-18 months), they can get back the $25 or invest it in another individual’s dreams and wellbeing. While one of my young friends told me he’d rather have had the money, the others have been truly excited about getting to invest in a business of their choice. And the added benefit is they can track the progress and care about someone they’ve never met, who is definitely less fortunate than they.

Reducing holiday stress

Besides unresolved conflicts, expectations and disappointments, and what ever other emotional stress a holiday might present, a large portion of stress can be attributed to finances.

According to an Experian survey, 58% said they end up spending too much money during the holiday season, and holiday spending is expected to rise – along with consumers’ financial stress levels. It found that most stress comes from unexpected expenses, adding up to nearly $300, on top of the gifts they’re already planning on giving. Ironically, those most likely to overspend are Americans aged 25 to 34; a group especially concerned with their debt levels.

This survey also offers some good gift ideas, like making a contribution to a loved one’s college savings plan rather than buying toys or other goods, or giving yourself the gift of a little extra cash in your savings or 401(k) accounts if you can.

As with all finances, the greatest way to reduce stress is to budget and plan ahead. Although this year’s holiday season is almost upon us, one good rule of thumb is: if you have to put it on a credit card, don’t buy it.

Using credit cards: Besides the caveat of using them judiciously and paying off the balance within the grace period, you may want to read WalletHub’s recommendations for two key holiday credit card benefits: price protection, for a refund if the price of a purchase drops soon after the holidays, and purchase protection that can help repair or replace recent purchases that are damaged or stolen. And their 2018’s Best Credit Cards for Holiday Shopping.

Plan ahead for next year!

If you’d like less stress next holiday season, give yourself the gift of starting to plan now.

– Track what you actually spend this year, so you can see where you might save next year.
– Save more throughout the year. You don’t have to spend it!
– Make and buy travel-related plans months in advance.
– As you go through the year and see an item on sale, at a flea market, in your travels or wherever that “remind” you of someone you care about, buy it and put it away in a closet. Then, come the holidays, you may have all or most of your gifts ready to be wrapped and given with pleasure, eliminating stress and increased last-minute costs.

We can’t turn back the clock to the days when consumerism was not so insane or debt inducing, but we can be more creative, and we can take responsibility for our own choices. If anyone will love you less for not spending more, then you decide what that is worth.

Wishing you a happy, stress-free, best ever holiday season!

Aysha Griffin, Communications Director for The Merriman Financial Education Foundation since 2012, is a certified business coach, providing practical guidance and support services for successful “third act” Passion Projects. She also loves empowering women of newly inherited wealth to make sound financial decisions. She can be reached via email.

Purchase on Amazon


Sound Investing Podcast

Top 10 MW Articles